Malorthodoxy By David Harwood

Shavuah Tov {{firstName}},

Malorthodoxy
By David Harwood

A number of years ago I came home from a Friday evening meeting. My body was exhausted, but my mind was quite lively. I was tired. And I was dealing with adrenaline, so I was not able to sleep. I was tired and I was wired. So I came up with a new word: twired. I like words, and so I was quite pleased with myself, thinking that perhaps I had coined a new one. However, I went on Google and found that the word had already been used. (I still use it.)

Well, last week something like this happened again. I was thinking of how people have to live under an unjust society which has confused that which is wrong with that which is right. The Scriptures speak of calling light darkness and darkness light.

Oy to those who call evil good and good evil, who present darkness as light and light as darkness, who present bitter as sweet, and sweet as bitter! (Isaiah 5:20)

And I came up with a new word: malorthodoxy. At least I thought it was a new word. So I checked with Google and found no one using that word. Then I checked with my AI and found the same thing. And so, I commend to you, for your use, the word malorthodoxy. Along with it come malorthodox and other forms of the same word. You will find them at the end.

By the way, as I was typing this, I needed to add the word malorthodoxy to Microsoft Word, because it thought it was a misspelling.

Here’s the definition I arrived at while interacting with the AI I generally use, Claude.

Malorthodoxy (n.): a bad belief or practice that a culture comes to accept as right, and that is then enforced, first by social pressure, then by lawsuits, courts and legislation, and finally by force, by people who believe they are doing right. Under a dictatorship or totalitarian government, the middle steps are not needed: the ruler’s will stands in for the law, and the courts, where they remain, only carry it out.

I want to let you know that the definition comes from me. I guided Claude in its expression, and the AI added a few of the related words. I really think that this word can be a tool we can use to describe this reality.

Malorthodoxy is held as correct; however, it is harmful. At first it is softly enforced by a community, and then it migrates to the power of the state. Those who enforce it are sincere. It ends up bringing a fairly common consensus into the society and producing uniformity.

Those who are malorthodox believe that they are defending that which is right. I want to mention that consensus is not necessarily the result of truth. Just because someone is sincere does not mean that they are acting righteously or believing that which is just.

In the Gospel of John, Yeshua warned His followers:

They will make you outcasts from the synagogue, but an hour is coming for everyone who kills you to think that he is offering service to God. (John 16:2 NASB)

And so here we find a common consensus, shaming, then official excommunication, and then violence, even murder, which is done as an act of devotion to God. Malorthodoxy.

Do we recall how, when the apostles were brought before the authorities, they said they had to obey God rather than men? I think we do.

Peter and the emissaries replied, “We must obey God rather than men.” (Acts 5:29)

Consider the Jim Crow laws. They followed a cultural consensus and produced laws, enforced by the state, that were abominable.

After years of indoctrination in Mao’s teaching, students became radicalized. They started the Red Guards. Mao turned them loose on China’s previous culture, seeking to cleanse it, to purify it from the customs and culture of prior generations. The Red Guards harmed and humiliated teachers, plundered, and turned neighbors against one another. They did this seeking to follow a higher moral path. They were obviously wrong. What they did was beyond the boundaries of law, and yet the state backed them up.

Certainly, we see this pattern during the rise of Hitler. Ultimately, the power of the state was utilized in the most brutal ways imaginable.

Where are there examples of malorthodoxy in the world today? Well, we can look at places like China, where that which is considered “orthodox” is actually abominable. Or we can look at Iran, where its regime enforces a form of orthodoxy which is, in fact, malorthodoxy.

Recently, Islamic fascists like ISIS have done the same thing. If you would take some time to read about what they did in beheading Coptic Christians in Libya, you would be saddened, and perhaps outraged. They believed that they were following righteousness in enslaving, torturing, raping and turning women into sex slaves. In 2016 it was reported that they put Yazidi women into cages and burned them alive. Did they have a twinge of conscience? Who knows? What we do know is that they believed that they were doing the right thing. This is malorthodoxy.

Other examples of malorthodoxy can be found in our culture, where some states can legislate that young girls must share locker rooms with naked boys. A woman in New Hampshire lost her gym membership for complaining about a man in the women’s locker room. Woke ideology is following in this pattern.

Right now we see anti-Zionism and antisemitism becoming a common consensus, from the fringes of the right and, horrifyingly, within the liberal establishment. It goes all the way over to the anti-colonialist willingness to destroy Israel “from the river to the sea,” and to persecute or even kill the Jewish people throughout the world. This is malorthodoxy.

It needs to be stood against. And the only way that we will be able to stand when the zeitgeist, which is actually a real spiritual conspiracy of demonic principalities, becomes a more common consensus, ultimately legislated, upheld by courts and enforced by the state, is to settle now whom we will serve.

As Joshua said:
But as for me and my household, we will worship Adonai! (Joshua 24:15)

Glossary
malorthodox (adj.): belonging to a malorthodoxy. “A malorthodox law.”
malorthodoxies (n. pl.): the cases themselves. “The malorthodoxies of our age.”
the malorthodox (n.): those who hold or enforce a malorthodoxy.
malorthopraxy (n.): a malorthodoxy of practice, used when the practice rather than the belief is in view.
malorthoprax or malorthopractic (adj.): belonging to a malorthopraxy.

Scripture quotations are from the Tree of Life Version, except John 16:2, from the New American Standard Bible (1995).

Daily Bread, reading plan by Lars Enarson (https://www.thewatchman.org/)
Sun      22-Nov-2026             12th of Kislev, 5787
Ge 32:4-13                 1 Sa 2              Ps 44               Mk 4:1-20      (1 Co 4)

David Harwood

Recent

Archive

 2026

Categories

Tags